TaxValet | Sales Tax Blog | State laws, E-commerce, SaaS

Navigating the Impact of New Tariffs on Your Shopify Business | TaxValet

Written by Jessie Esposito | Apr 1, 2025 12:31:41 PM

Recent tariffs imposed on goods imported from countries like Canada, China, and Mexico can significantly impact the profitability of your Shopify store, especially if you source products internationally. Many Shopify sellers now face the critical question: "How can I effectively pass tariff-related costs on to my customers?"

In this blog, we’ll dive directly into practical strategies Shopify sellers can use to manage tariff costs, maintain profit margins, and clearly communicate these fees to customers.

Defining Your Business Goals

Before implementing a tariff recovery strategy, it’s essential to assess your business goals. The approach you take will depend on your priorities, like:

  • Cost recovery: Is your primary focus ensuring that tariff costs are fully recovered while maintaining consistent profit margins?

  • Transparency: Is it important that you’re clearly communicating your policies to customers?

  • Consistent customer experience: Is maintaining a smooth and seamless checkout process your top priority?
Your strategy may vary depending on which of these factors matter most to your business.


Exploring Tariff Recovery Options in Shopify

Many Shopify sellers source products from multiple manufacturers across different countries. In light of this, the ideal tariff recovery solution should allow you to apply surcharges at the product level rather than as a blanket fee at checkout. 

But how do you implement this in your Shopify store? Here are some potential solutions you can consider: 

1. Native Shopify Solution

Shopify’s API allows sellers to create custom fee structures at the product level through coding.

Pros:

  • No additional monthly fees
  • Does not require third-party app integrations

Cons: 

  • Requires advanced coding knowledge
  • Not ideal for businesses without in-house development expertise
  • Hiring a developer could be costly

2. Shopify integration with Magical Fees & Surcharges

Magical Apps has developed a user-friendly solution that allows merchants to apply tariff surcharges at a product level. The Magical Fees & Surcharges app is available in the Shopify App Store.

Pros:

  • Applies fees at the product level
  • Displays a disclaimer on product pages: “Product-based fees may apply at checkout”
  • Shows the surcharge as a separate line item at checkout

Cons:

  • Additional cost to your Shopify subscription starting at $9.99/month
  • Not compatible with draft orders 

 

3. Shopify integration with Upcharge Fees Addons Surcharge

Mageworx offers another solution for applying tariff surcharges to Shopify products: Upcharge Fees Addons Surcharge. It’s also available in the Shopify App Store.

Pros:

  • Can attach fees to specific products or entire carts
  • Provides the most customization options

Cons:

  • Additional cost to your Shopify subscription at $9.99/month
  • Not compatible with a POS system

 
 

Other Considerations

  • Know your product sources: You’ll need to be able to identify the source country of each product in your Shopify store to apply surcharges correctly.

  • Clear Communication: Whether you increase product prices, implement tariff surcharges, or absorb the cost, transparency is key. Clearly label tariff-related charges and update your shipping policy on your website to reflect your approach.

Final Thoughts

Navigating the impact of tariffs on your business requires a strategic approach that aligns with your business values, customer experience goals, and your earnings goals. Staying informed on the ever-changing policies and timelines will be essential. If you need guidance on implementing a strategy, don’t hesitate to reach out. We’re here to help.